Pumpernickel's Bagelry

5504 Connecticut Avenue
Washington, DC 20015

Pizza, Pasta, and Hot Heros!

Pizza Delivery: Minimum order for pizza delivery is three pizzas. You can add salads and dessert or drinks to bring the order up to the minimum if you want less pizza. One Pizza will serve at least four people. Please give us as much advance notice as possible, and allow us to add a gratuity.

Pizza Slices: All slices are $3.50 each.

Carry out Specials: Available every day. Slice selections include Plain, Pepperoni, Vegetable, Meat Lovers, White, Pesto, Greek, BBQ, Vegan, Italian Sausage, Sicilian, Greek, Portobello Mushroom, and more!
  #1 One slice and a medium fountain drink. $4.75
  #2 Two slices and a medium fountain drink. $8.00
  #3 One slice, a small soup or small salad, and a medium fountain drink. $8.00
  #4 Any two slices, a small soup or salad and a fountain drink. $10.00

Whole Pies

(All Pies Are $21. Some special pies are a little extra.)

Plain Cheese Pie: The standard cheese pizza pie! Fresh mozzarella over our basil tomato sauce!

Plain Cheese Sicilian: Just like in Sicily! Rectangular, deep-dish Pizza, cooked twice with extra sauce. Sicilian may require 24 Hour Notice! $2 Extra

Extra Cheese: Our plain cheese pizza with even more mozzarella!

Pepperoni: Thin sliced fresh spicy pepperoni, generously spread!

Sausage Peppers and Onions: Our own Italian Sausage cooked and sliced with green and red peppers, plus onions....delicious!

Meatballs: The way Momma used to make em! Sliced thinly and spread generously!

Greek Pizza: Take a trip to Greece via Italy! Mozzarella and Greek Feta Cheeses, onions, green peppers, red peppers, and black olives!

Eggplant Parmesan: We slice fresh Eggplant and spread the slices under the cheese. This preparation is a Brooklyn specialty!

Classic Margherita Pizza: Oven baked with Buffalo mozzarella cheese (mozzarella di bufala), and fresh basil leaves.

Sun Dried Tomato: Chopped Sun Dried Tomatoes spread over a cheese Pizza with fresh basil.

Fresh Basil: Fresh Basil leaves spread over our Mozzarella cheese Pie.

White Pesto and Tomato: Fresh Pesto and Tomato slices spread over a white Pizza with Olive Oil, fresh Garlic, and Rosemary!

Portobello Mushroom: Fresh sliced Portobello Mushrooms over our cheese Pizza.

Mushroom: Traditional freshly sliced mushrooms over our cheese Pizza.

Onion: An onion lover's dream! The onions cook nicely during their 8 minute journey to the stone hearth oven!

Grilled Chicken Caesar Pizza: Grilled Chicken, Romaine lettuce, Caesar Dressing, and Croutons top this delicious Pie.

Peppers and Onions: Bermuda Onions with fresh sliced green and red peppers, cooked right into the cheese!

Caramelized Bermuda Onions: Everybody loves Caramelized Bermuda onions, try it on Pizza!

Black Olives: Vito Corleone loved Black olives, a pizza you can't refuse!

Vegetable Supreme: All the veggies we have, with fresh spinach and black olives too!

Vegan Pizza: Dairy Free Vegan Cheese with mixed vegetables. See description at the bottom of this page. $3 Extra

Cheese-less Vegetable Supreme: For those who don't do cheese! Everything on the Vegetable Supreme Pizza, but without the dairy.

Meat Lover's: Where's the beef? It's on this pizza! Sausage, pepperoni, beef, salami, and chicken!

Meat Lover's Sicilian: Same as the meat lover's above, but Sicilian style! Sicilian Pizza is a deep dish rectangle pizza, cooked twice with a little extra sauce! $2 Extra

Grandma Sicilian: Our classic Sicilian pie, cooked twice, with an onion, tomato, and garlic sauce. Prepared without cheese. All the rave in NYC! $2 Extra

White Pizza: Instead of a red sauce we use an olive oil mix with garlic and rosemary.

Fancy White Pizza: Olive Oil, fresh garlic, spinach, feta cheese, mushrooms, and Rosemary, top this popular pie!

Italian Hero Pizza: Topped with lettuce, tomato, and onion we add Italian ham, pepperoni, Genoa salami, and mozzarella cheese!

Hawaiian: Sliced Ham and Fresh Pineapple.> (Some call it a California Pizza)!

Philly Cheese Steak Pizza: Rib eye steak with sliced mushrooms, and caramelized onions! We hold the mayo though!

Barbecue Chicken: Fresh cubes of chicken breast soaked in barbecue sauce and a little hot sauce, cooked into the Pizza. It's great!

Shrimp; Fresh grilled Shrimp in a white garlic sauce over our white Pizza! $10 Extra

Pizza Toppings

$3.00 per topping

Pepperoni Red/Green Peppers Meatballs Grilled Chicken
Sausage Mushrooms Black Olives Tomatoes
BBQ Chicken Shrimp ($10 Extra) Spinach Squash
Ham Zucchini Fried Chicken Greek Feta Cheese
Buffalo Chicken Spanish Onions Bermuda Onions Anchovies ($5.00 Extra)
Fresh Basil Pesto and Tomato Grilled Chicken

Hot Parmesan Heros

Prepared with marinara sauce, mozzarella and parmesan cheese, then toasted in the oven.

Meatball Parmesan $6.95
Sausage and Peppers Parmesan $6.95
Chicken Cutlet Parmesan $6.95
Vegan/Vegetarian Meatball with melted soy cheese $6.95

Calzones: We make our Calzones with ricotta cheese, sausage, peppers, onions, pepperoni, and mozzarella cheese, wrapped in Pizza dough then baked in the oven. Marinara sauce served on the side.
$6.95 each

Garlic Knots and Pesto Garlic Knots: Our own Pizza dough stuffed with olive oil, garlic and pesto with all the right seasonings.
$25 for 16 knots

Sicilian Garlic Squares with Spincach and Feta: Sixteen fresh squares of sicilian pizza bread with garlic, olive oil, mozzarella cheese, feta, and spinach. One day notice required.
$25 each pie

Vegan and Vegetarian Pizza: We make fresh dough every day. Pizza dough when made correctly does not contain dairy. Our homemade sauce is made from fresh whole pear tomatoes, basil, and spices. We use only shreded dairy-free "cheese". Select either vegetable, mock meats, veggie meatballs, or just plain. Pizzas made like this are fat-free as well as delicious. Our vegan pizzas are 18 inches in diameter and are cut into eight big slices. One Pie feeds four people.
$24 Each Pie